Asleep at the Wheel

You can’t have a government “of, by, and for the people” if the people don’t participate. When Americans are distracted from politics, avoid learning about politics, or think all politicians are dirty so there are no real choices among them, our government does not serve the people. It only serves those who participate.

In 2010, the Supreme Court decided in the Citizens United ruling that money equals speech. They argued that limiting campaign contributions is the same thing as limiting our right to free speech. This unbelievably harmful ruling ensures that big money rules our elections. The rich can spend so much on campaigns that they drown out whatever ordinary people are trying to say.

Trump and his billionaires are the end result of a process that has been going on for decades. Ordinary Americans should be driving this car, but most have been too distracted or too cynical to do the job. Instead, the very rich have pushed us aside. They have taken the wheel of American politics so that they can just keep on getting richer. The politicians they put in power are the ones who will do what they want. This means lower taxes for the rich, higher taxes for the rest of us, fewer regulations, and less oversight, so they can get away with more monkey business.

Now Trump’s administration is in the process of destroying the working parts of our government. They are not trying to throw out the bathwater and keep the baby. They’re throwing the baby out too. Education? Medical research? Food safety? Consumer protection? Environmental rules that fight climate change? The billionaires have decided we don’t need any of that.

It’s much easier to destroy things than to build them. It took a long time and a lot of work to get our government to help people in crisis, take care of the elderly, educate children with special needs, and keep industry from spoiling our air and water. Now all the structures that were so carefully put in place to help ordinary Americans are being torn down as fast as the billionaires can manage.

For a long time, Americans have allowed ourselves to believe that we don’t have to participate in politics. What difference does one vote make, after all? The problem is that if millions of people think this way, it makes a huge difference.

Trump and his billionaire besties are driving this car right over a cliff. His tariffs make everything we need more expensive, not cheaper. He is turning our allies into enemies, and making friends with dictators. He is leaving our country at the mercy of the next epidemic, in spite of all we learned from COVID. Instead of negotiating fair deals for the resources we need, he threatens to take them by force.

It won’t be easy to take the wheel back from the billionaire class that has grabbed it. They are ruthless, they own most of the media, and they don’t care whom they hurt. They will lie, cheat, and use violence to keep themselves in power.

But that car belongs to us, the people of the United States. We have a Constitution for a reason. For all the faults of that document, it does insist that the country belongs to the people who live here, not just the rich and powerful. If we pay attention, if we decide to participate, we can take this country back.

It is tempting to sleep through this era of loss and destruction. But the only way to rescue our country is to wake up to our power to change things. Too many of us have left the driving to others. We need to take the wheel and steer ourselves back toward peace, justice, and a sustainable future.

More Jews for Justice

The People Speak

Ever since Trump and Musk began to take a chainsaw to the work of generations, I’ve been hearing, “Where is the outrage?” Go to a protest near you; you will find that outrage.

On Thursday, March 26, I went to Tufts for a rally against the abduction the day before of Rumeysa Ozturk, a Turkish doctoral student at the school. She was snatched by masked federal agents as she walked toward a friend’s house, handcuffed, and driven away in an unmarked car. Before a judge could order that the government not take her out of Massachusetts, she had already been spirited away to an ICE detention center in Louisiana.

Ozturk was grabbed without any form of due process. She was in the United States legally on a student visa. She had done nothing wrong. About a year ago, she objected to Tufts’s refusal to divest from Israel in an opinion piece in the student paper. Trump & company have decided that anyone who uses their freedom of speech in a way they don’t like is a threat to national security, maybe even a terrorist.

Outspoken international students are low-hanging fruit. Trump means to pick them and throw them somewhere to rot. He doesn’t have to abduct all of them, just enough to shut the rest of them up.

But students are not shutting up. Ozturk’s abduction, added to the equally outrageous detention of Mahmoud Khalil, a Columbia student, three weeks ago, and the rendition of  more than 250 Venezuelans to the worst prison in El Salvador with no proof that any of them were criminals or gang members, has pushed many into activism.

The Tufts rally comprised about 2000 people, most with handmade signs. Never mind the speakers, whom I couldn’t hear anyway. This is what their signs said:

An injury to one is an injury to all.
Free Rumeysa!
Democracy NOT deportation protects Jewish students
We will not be silenced!
Silencing dissent is the REAL cancel culture
If not fascism, then why fascism-shaped?
Democracy > Deportation
Release all prisoners of the secret police
Democracy is under attack!
Speak out against injustice or you’re gonna be silenced next
I love inclusion, equality, diversity
Stop doing evil shit
Abolish ICE
ICE out of our communities! Free Palestine!
Jews Against Deportation
This Tufts alum affirms the equal dignity and humanity of all people
Nice Jewish Students for Democracy
(a ten year old with a rainbow sign) RESIST!
Jewish Civil Liberty
Hands off our neighbors
Find courage/ find community/ fight fascism
They want us scared/ We’ll show them our strength
This is fucking insane
Free Rumeysa – Free speech
It starts with students!
You wanna mess with our freedoms? You gotta go through me!
Stop kidnapping students.
You can’t appease a dictator!
Show your face when you steal our students.
This is OUR Somerville.
Immigrants make us great.
Don’t sleepwalk through fascism.
Stand together.
Never normalize kidnapping.
Melt ICE
Silence is complicity.
When speech is silenced, Revolution speaks.
First they come for the scholars.
Against Genocide Anywhere.
(More signs from a small, poorly organized protest in Harvard Square the next day:)
In the name of humanity, we refuse to accept a fascist America
Hands off legal students and visitors
Stop the fascist assault
I(ncompetent) C(ruel) E(xpensive)
Due process rights for ALL people (see the 5th amendment)
Our tax dollars fund genocide
In the name of humanity, let in asylum seekers and refugees
Deport ICE not students
1st amendment? Hello???

Project 2025 indicates that it won’t be long before Trump uses the military against peaceful demonstrators. There will be tear gas, pepper spray, and water hoses, mass arrests, and eventually, rubber bullets or worse.

Meanwhile, Trump is damaging everything we love: our communities, education, alliances with other democracies, the environment, and most of all our rights. Democracy is clearly under attack. As Americans realize how much harm is being done, we get angrier, maybe even angry enough to get up off the couch and do something.

The protests are becoming more frequent, and the crowds keep getting bigger. If you’re not on the streets already, I hope you will join us soon. The homemade, passionate, outraged signs at every rally help me to believe that maybe we can save democracy. Not leaders or heroes, or the corporate-owned Democrats. We, the people. 

Made Stupid

It’s depressing how little most Americans know, and how little they want to know. The refusal to wear masks or get vaccinated is only one example. More Americans believe in angels than in evolution. Enough Americans believe that Trump won the last election to put our democracy in real danger.

People are not born stupid. Anyone who has been fortunate enough to spend time around babies knows that we’re born curious, observant, and eager to connect the dots of experience. It takes years of conditioning to make people stupid.

Our consumer economy relies on an adequate supply of stupidity. If we could not be convinced to buy stuff we don’t need, the bottom would fall out of the global marketplace. Today’s deep hole would look like a pockmark. A critical number of Americans must believe that this perfume will make us sexy, this car will make us happy, this drink will make us high achievers. No ad suggests we should save our money or cut our consumption. We are trained to keep shopping.

photo by Phoebe Potter

Stupidity training starts as soon as we plunk a baby in front of a screen. The ads never stop after that, telling our children to want things that their families can’t afford, making them hungry for food that is bad for their health, convincing them they must have toys they would do better without. The average American child views more than 40,000 television ads every year, and more through social media. There is no counter-programming in schools, although learning how to spot a con should be required curriculum.

By default, we leave counter-programming up to parents, but most parents aren’t home to teach it. Ever since the cost of living outpaced income growth in the 1970s, it has taken two incomes to support a family. Women were forced to go to work whether they wanted to or not. The question of who was going to take care of the children was never faced by the federal government. Every family had to figure that out for themselves. Often the answer involved unqualified caregivers, or no caregivers at all – inaugurating the age of latch-key kids.

Now we have had more than two generations of children who were left pretty much to their own devices after school. Unfortunately their devices were usually television, or, more recently, cell phones.

Meanwhile, public education has been steadily degraded, although teachers and administrators still try valiantly to make it work. Republican administrations particularly have had it in for education; a well-informed public trained to observe, analyze, and think critically would never support cutting taxes for the rich, or waging unprovoked war, or subsidizing the fossil fuel industry. In other words, it would never elect Republicans.

Shortly after President Carter created a cabinet-level Department of Education, Reagan called for its total elimination, and succeeded in severely cutting its funding. When Reagan entered office, the federal share of total education funding was 12%; when he left 8 years later, the share was 6%. His Education Secretary, William Bennett, a neoconservative, oversaw these cuts in order to weaken public education in favor of private and religious schooling.

George W. Bush signed the No Child Left Behind Act, which punished poor schools for failing without funding effective remedies. Trump put Betsy DeVos in charge of public education because of her lifelong devotion to private education.

Racism has played its part. Once public schools were integrated, white parents began to take their children out of the system. People with money put their children in private schools or moved to rich suburbs where taxes on expensive real estate resulted in good public schools. This removed parents with power and influence from PTAs and school boards in disadvantaged neighborhoods. White people with less money turned to religious schools.

Private schools make sure kids learn a second language early, experience music and arts, take field trips to museums and farms. Poor kids enter the lottery for charter schools or do without all that. Their teachers are forced to “teach to the test,” without the flexibility to teach anything but basic math and literacy. Most of the things that make school fun have disappeared.

State and local education funding account for 90% of what we spend on schools. School budgets were cut by an average of 7% during the decade following the 2008 recession, with predictable results. The 2015 Programme for International Student Assessment study of 15 year olds ranked the US 38th out of 71 countries in math and 24th in science. Less than half of Americans are proficient readers. The pandemic, and the remote learning it required, has made things immeasurably worse.

4 out of 10 Americans believe humans and dinosaurs coexisted. 1 out of 4 believe the sun revolves around the earth. Almost half believe in ghosts. 4 out of 10 think homosexual people choose their own orientation. The poll didn’t ask why they think anybody would do that. 6 out of 10 believe that dreams predict the future. An astounding 3 out of 4 believe there is indisputable evidence that alien beings have visited Earth. How far away do they think the nearest stars really are, and do they know that the speed of light limits how fast anything can travel? The answers would indisputably be disturbing.

Possibly even more significant than American ignorance about science is our ignorance about our democracy. Only 9 states and Washington DC require a full year of education in civics or US governance. Most states require half a year. 11 states require none at all. Until the 1960s, most schools required three separate courses on American government.

Nearly half of Americans cannot identify the three branches of government. 1 out of 4 believe the USA won its independence from some nation other than Great Britain. 3 out of 4 do not know that the Bill of Rights prohibits the establishment of an official religion in the US. Most Americans believe we spend around 25% of our budget on foreign aid; the real figure is under 1%.

Ignorance is self-reinforcing. If you’re ever embarrassed by not knowing a subject, it’s much easier to mock the people who do know it as intellectual snobs than to learn about it yourself. You’re managing to feed and clothe yourself, so you really didn’t need to know that thing anyway, right? And it’s a comfort that your friends don’t know it either. Gradually, we have slid into a situation where knowing things makes a person different, alien, not normal.

We can stop being so stupid, but it’s going to take time and money. We can hire more teachers and pay them much better. We can stop funneling public money to charter and religious schools. People who believe in education can run for school board. We can put civics, history, geography, and the arts back into curricula. We can lengthen the school day and invite community members in to teach what they know.

Intellectuals and academics can venture out of the ivory tower and start talking to the rest of us again. The media might consider what we need to know in a time of drastic climate change and food insecurity, instead of feeding us the empty calories of celebrity gossip.

Stupidity might be good for the corporate bottom line, but it’s terrible for humanity’s bottom line. We got this far by being smart and creative. We can only keep going if we wise up. Vote Democratic. It’s our best shot at surviving our epidemic of Dumb.

America: love it or hate it

I love America because people are here from everywhere. First generation keeps the old languages and customs; second generation is just American kids who drive the old folks crazy. Doesn’t matter where you came from. If you’re here, this is where you belong. Our immigrant and refugee policies are terrible (file under reasons to hate America) but our immigrants and refugees enrich our lives in so many ways: food, music, expanding dialogues, businesses, interesting neighborhoods.

I hate America because racism, xenophobia (fear of strangers), and misogyny (fear of women) are so deeply embedded in our culture. Too many of us have accepted them as though there was nothing we could do about them. I hate America because we take democracy for granted and 40% of us don’t bother to vote. I hate America because we’ve been bullying the whole world, bragging about torturing people, terrifying the Middle East with our armed drones. And refusing to acknowledge climate change even after New Orleans and the wildfires in California. Not to mention keeping the pandemic going, all by ourselves if we have to, because…freedom?

I love America because of our ideals of equality before the law, free speech, and human rights. I hate America’s failure to live up to them. I love that so many of us are trying to finally make democracy real.

These clips

I’m posting two clips from Youtube that sum up the moment we’re in and how we got here. I have nothing to add, except my heartfelt hope that this all leads to changes black Americans have needed for a long time. The videos of horrific police violence, the personal stories of suffering from police racism and the racism so common in our society: these are reaching hearts and minds. Ultimately, such attitude shifts within individuals form the change in public consciousness that is the only thing that has ever taken us in the direction we have to go. People are fighting for a future where we can all survive and thrive. Let us support them in any way we can. Black lives matter.

That Pimple

Trump is just the ugly boy up front.
He’s the pus-filled peak of the pimple of greed and violence.

Trump distracts the people while Greed and Violence suck all our wealth toward the richest. They get the money.

We get work that won’t pay our bills, crumbling infrastructure, the ruin of the climate.

While zillionaires get huge tax cuts, they cut everything ordinary people need.

Parks, libraries, schools, hospitals: cut.
Street and sewer maintenance: cut.

Safety inspections: cut. Food stamps: cut.
Pandemic supplies: oh, oops, gave them to China.

The ones in power are the worst people in the world.
The ones in power don’t care how many of us die.

They don’t care if we’re afraid for our lives or our livelihoods. They don’t care if we have nowhere to live.

The ones in power don’t care.
Good thing we, the people, do.

We donate and volunteer. We make masks.
We grow Victory gardens. We give things away.

Disregarding the Pimple, we listen to Science.
We wear the masks. We staff the food banks.

While our so-called leader
hides with his phone,

tweeting hatred and lies all day,
the People are stepping up.

Watch out, zillionaires.
One of these days the People

might even vote.